The Relative Performance of the Economy under the Presidents of the United States from 1900 to 2026

Revised October 2026*


Samuel H. Williamson

Founder of MeasuringWorth

 and 

Professor of Economics Emeritus Miami University 

sam@mswth.org

With assistance from

Ben Hogewood

MeasuringWorth Research Associate

Economic performance has been an important issue in elections for decades. Voters look at economic variables to gain some insight into the incumbent's record. The health of our economy, however, is determined by monetary and fiscal policy, external shocks, and even bubbles. The economy faced by an incumbent president and Congress, good or bad, is the result of events that occurred before as well as during his term of office. Elections have been won and lost by the timing of the business cycle where incumbents were caught on the right or wrong side of the slope. Of course, this does not stop claims and blames during election campaigns. Some are rhetorical, such as "the best economy ever" or "you are worse off than you were two or four years ago." Others are specific such as "your taxes are higher today than they were" or "the unemployment rate fell last month." In many cases, these statements have little context or are misleading. For example, taxes may be higher than four years ago, but, at that time, there may have been a one-time rebate to deal with a recession, or the unemployment rate may have fallen, but from an unusually high rate. 

The goal of this paper is to help the reader better understand how the economy performed during each of the presidential terms from 1900 to 2026. It was updated in October of 2026 to include the first eighteen months of the second Trump term. For all the Presidents in the 21st century we also present the performances during the first three years of their terms.  This is done so the comparisons of Trump’s first-term performance with others can also be made excluding his last year in office when there was a 9% drop in real GDP during the Covid epidemic.

Sources 

MeasuringWorth is a website devoted to presenting the best historical time series of economic data and providing comparators that help make useful comparisons of these data. The tables presented here can be reproduced easily using data from the MeasuringWorth website, FRED, and government sources.1 They can be studied using the site's Annualized Growth Comparator, which analyzes the growth of dozens of variables. The tables use annual data from 1900 to 2026 augmented by quarterly or monthly data when available.

Comments on Data.

 The data are reported for each president. A separate observation has been created for those terms in which a Vice President succeeded to the presidency. In four cases, this was a result of the President's death; in one case, the President's resignation.2 For example, there is one observation encompassing FDR's first three terms, one for the term in which he died and Truman took over, and one for the term that Truman was elected. For the annual data we have set the length of a Presidential term as change in levels from the year the President was elected, to the year of the next election. Thus, we have four years of observations.3

 The quarterly data sets the term from the quarter they were elected to the quarter their successor was elected. These were the quarters before they were inaugurated. And for the monthly labor data, we've used the January observations of the year they took office to the January of the year they left office.4

Stock and Flow Variables

There are two types of variables we use in talking about the economy. One is a stock variable, an economic quantity that, in principle, is measured at a point in time. Prices, tax rates, interest rates, home values, stock indexes and the price of gold are examples of stock variables. The other is a flow variable, which has a time dimension: it is measured over a period, such as a quarter or a year. Wages, incomes and output are flow variables. This distinction matters when comparing presidential terms, which are not all the same length. To make those comparisons, we convert most of the observations to be the annualized growth rate.

Gross Domestic Product (GDP) is the total market value of all final goods and services produced in a country during one year. Put another way, it is the total spending on newly produced goods and services. In the United States, annual GDP is about $31 trillion, meaning that much is spent on U.S. output each year.5

 Four groups buy what is produced. Households, buying food, cars, medical care, and whatever else they want and can afford, account for about 68 percent of GDP. Business firms purchasing new equipment, buildings, and inventories, along with households buying new homes, account for another 18 percent. Government spending on schools, highways, and Air Force F-16s takes up about 17 percent. Finally, foreign buyers of U.S. exports account for 11 percent.

 These shares add up to more than 100 percent because about 14 percent of what Americans spend goes to goods and services produced overseas. Imports must be subtracted to get an accurate measure of domestic product.

 Three of these sectors (households, businesses, and foreign buyers) respond to market forces that are influenced by macroeconomic policy. Government spending is different: it rests on legislative decisions, from the local town council to the U.S. Congress. In 1944, for example, government spending on World War II and personal consumption each made up 48 percent of GDP. By 1947, government spending had fallen to 16 percent of GDP, and consumer spending had risen to a peacetime level of 65 percent.

 The Consumer Price Index (CPI) is a weighted measure of the cost of a bundle of things that the average household buys. In theory, it is the cost at a point in time or a stock variable.6

 In the tables that follow, we report the changes in these series over each term rather than their levels.

 There are many concerns when making comparisons over time. One problem is that, while the name remains the same, these variables measure different things over time. GDP is a measure of total product in each year, but what is produced each year changes, and so does the bundle of things the CPI prices. In 2024, 1.2 billion smartphones were produced; in 1990 there were none. There was no TV or internet in the 1930s. Further, there was no government agency measuring the GDP before the Great Depression, so those observations have been estimated by historians. Their earlier measures of prices and output are far less accurate than those of today. 

 The first table presents annualized growth rates of key economic variables for the terms of 23 presidents. It covers real GDP, and real GDP per capita, the inflation rate, the growth in the S&P stock index, population, and the price of gold. Each variable has had its ups and downs (sometimes coincidental) during the presidential terms.

 Economic growth, measured either as the growth in real GDP or real GDP per capita, is the most often used measure of a President’s success in managing the economy, whether or not they have had any control over the sources of growth.7

 Inflation, as measured by the rate of increase in the CPI, was highest during the Wilson administration because of World War One and the Roosevelt/Truman term because of the ending of the World War II price controls.

 Another period of high inflation was during the Nixon/Ford and Carter administrations when the Federal Reserve was increasing the money supply at a rapid rate. Ford and Carter were both criticized for not being able to bring inflation under control, and both lost the elections of 1976 and 1980, respectively. Biden received similar criticism during the 2024 campaign, and inflation has since run at 2.63% in 2025 and above 3% through mid-2026.

 Stock prices rose during every administration, except Hoover's. Only during the Wilson, Nixon/Ford, Carter and G. W. Bush administrations did the stock index grow slower than the inflation rate. We will have more on stock index comparisons below.

 Gold has only been a true market commodity for part of the time.8 It is easy to see the relationship between its price and the inflation rate during the Nixon/Ford and Carter administrations. As inflation increased, gold was bought as a hedge against the falling value of the dollar. Gold prices and the stock market can be countercyclical as took place during the G. W. Bush administration. The 43.12% rise in the price of gold in 2025 is the largest in any term since the Carter administration.

 Population generally grew fastest during the early years of the 20th century, up to the 1920s. This was due to higher birth and immigration rates. The rate of growth dropped during the Depression, then increased because of the post-World War II baby boom. During the 21st century, the population growth rate has fallen to its lowest levels ever, a little over half a percent a year, as birth rates have continued to fall and migration has been more restricted than in the first half of the 20th century.

Table 1 -- The Annualized Growth Rate of Economic Measures during Presidential terms from 1900 to 2026

President Term Years Real GDP Real GDP per Capita CPI S&P Index Population Gold
Theodore Roosevelt 1901 to 1908 1.82% -0.11% 1.15% 5.82% 1.94% 0.00%
William Howard Taft 1909 to 1912 4.01% 2.16% 1.32% 12.84% 1.82% -0.03%
Woodrow Wilson 1913 to 1920 2.22% 0.82% 9.92% 5.92% 1.39% 3.65%
Harding/ Coolidge 1921 to 1924 4.73% 2.93% -3.89% 6.32% 1.75% -4.57%
Calvin Coolidge 1925 to 1928 2.72% 1.33% 0.04% 24.82% 1.37% -2.42%
Herbert Hoover 1929 to 1932 -5.67% -6.62% -5.50% -12.11% 0.91% 8.58%
F. D. Roosevelt 1933 to 1944 9.09% 8.17% 2.13% 8.59% 0.86% 2.98%
Roosevelt/Truman 1945 to 1948 -2.58% -3.97% 8.15% 10.72% 1.46% 0.00%
Harry S. Truman 1949 to 1952 5.00% 3.23% 2.47% 20.23% 1.72% 0.00%
Dwight D. Eisenhower 1953 to 1960 2.99% 1.19% 1.38% 16.24% 1.78% 0.20%
Kennedy/Johnson 1961 to 1964 4.69% 3.14% 1.17% 10.47% 1.51% -0.13%
Lyndon B. Johnson 1965 to 1968 5.18% 4.00% 2.91% 8.84% 1.13% 2.47%
Richard M. Nixon 1969 to 1972 2.95% 1.80% 4.72% 5.38% 1.12% 10.73%
Nixon/Ford 1973 to 1976 2.53% 1.56% 8.00% 2.08% 0.96% 21.04%
Jimmy Carter 1977 to 1980 3.24% 2.13% 9.67% 8.41% 1.09% 48.83%
Ronald Reagan 1981 to 1988 3.45% 2.51% 4.63% 15.45% 0.92% -4.13%
George H. W. Bush 1989 to 1992 2.23% 1.03% 4.36% 17.30% 1.19% -5.83%
Bill Clinton 1993 to 2000 3.88% 2.66% 2.59% 19.06% 1.19% -2.57%
George W. Bush (3 years) 2001 to 2003 1.81% 0.84% 2.23% -13.09% 0.96% 9.20%
George W. Bush 2001 to 2008 2.20% 1.24% 2.83% 1.21% 0.95% 15.31%
Barack H. Obama (3 years) 2009 to 2011 0.54% -0.30% 1.47% -0.09% 0.84% 21.70%
Barack H. Obama 2009 to 2016 1.66% 0.85% 1.37% 6.47% 0.80% 4.61%
Donald Trump 1st (3 years) 2017 to 2019 2.67% 2.05% 2.13% 12.99% 0.60% 3.66%
Donald Trump 1st 2017 to 2020 1.46% 0.90% 1.90% 16.50% 0.55% 9.09%
Joseph R. Biden (3 years) 2021 to 2023 3.86% 3.32% 5.59% 8.11% 0.52% 3.10%
Joseph R. Biden 2021 to 2024 3.63% 3.00% 4.93% 11.69% 0.62% 7.99%
Donald Trump 2nd (1 year) 2025 2.34% 1.79% 2.63% 25.93% 0.54% 43.12%

Table 2 -- Ranking the growth of the Economy during the President's term as measured using the Annualized Growth Rate of GDP (annual)

President Real GDP Growth President Real GDP per Capita Growth
F. D. Roosevelt 9.09% F. D. Roosevelt 8.17%
Lyndon B. Johnson 5.18% Lyndon B. Johnson 4.00%
Harry S. Truman 5.00% Joseph R. Biden (3 years) 3.32%
Harding/ Coolidge 4.73% Harry S. Truman 3.23%
Kennedy/Johnson 4.69% Kennedy/Johnson 3.14%
William Howard Taft 4.01% Joseph R. Biden 3.00%
Bill Clinton 3.88% Harding/ Coolidge 2.93%
Joseph R. Biden (3 years) 3.86% Bill Clinton 2.66%
Joseph R. Biden 3.63% Ronald Reagan 2.51%
Ronald Reagan 3.45% William Howard Taft 2.16%
Jimmy Carter 3.24% Jimmy Carter 2.13%
Dwight D. Eisenhower 2.99% Donald Trump 1st (3 years) 2.05%
Richard M. Nixon 2.95% Richard M. Nixon 1.80%
Calvin Coolidge 2.72% Donald Trump 2nd (1 year) 1.79%
Donald Trump 1st (3 years) 2.67% Nixon/Ford 1.56%
Nixon/Ford 2.53% Calvin Coolidge 1.33%
Donald Trump 2nd (1 year) 2.34% George W. Bush 1.24%
George H. W. Bush 2.23% Dwight D. Eisenhower 1.19%
Woodrow Wilson 2.22% George H. W. Bush 1.03%
George W. Bush 2.20% Donald Trump 1st 0.90%
Theodore Roosevelt 1.82% Barack H. Obama 0.85%
George W. Bush (3 years) 1.81% George W. Bush (3 years) 0.84%
Barack H. Obama 1.66% Woodrow Wilson 0.82%
Donald Trump 1st 1.46% Theodore Roosevelt -0.11%
Barack H. Obama (3 years) 0.54% Barack H. Obama (3 years) -0.30%
Roosevelt/Truman -2.58% Roosevelt/Truman -3.97%
Herbert Hoover -5.67% Herbert Hoover -6.62%

 These two tables rank the Presidents by the amount of annual growth in both real GDP and GDP per capita. For each President there were events that influenced growth during their term. Some might have been their policies; some might have been the policies of their predecessor; and most were probably the result of other things beyond their control.

 With these cautions in mind, FDR stands at the top of the lists. He took office near the trough of the Great Depression and died near the peak of the cycle, close to the end of World War II. Roosevelt/Truman ranks second to last,9 which is explained partly by the fall in government’s share of GDP from 42% to 16% between 1945 and 1947. Obama ranks near the bottom because he came to office in the middle of the Great Recession, the worst downturn since the Depression of the 1930s.

 We also see that of the top seven administrations on the list, five are Democrats. While some of this is explained by business cycles, and war and peace, the higher ranking of Clinton and Carter administrations is not. Of the twelve full terms at the bottom of the list, nine are Republicans.

 Table 3 separates the growth in GDP into the share contributed by government expenditures, and that from the private sector. Note, these are government expenditures and do not include transfer payments.10 The government share of GDP is not available until after WWII. Because Table 3 uses quarterly data, with each term measured from the quarter a president was elected to the quarter his successor was elected, its growth rates will not exactly match the annual figures in Tables 1 and 2.

Table 3 -- Annualized Growth rate of Quarterly GDP with and without the Government Share (quarterly observations in $billions)

Year & Quarter Real GDP Real Gov Expenditures GDP - Gov President GDP Growth Gov Growth GDP - Gov Growth
1948 IV 2,292 618 1,674
1952 IV 2,844 1,103 1,741 Truman 5.54% 15.59% 0.98%
1960 IV 3,470 1,187 2,284 Eisenhower 2.52% 0.91% 3.45%
1968 IV 5,202 1,723 3,479 Kennedy/Johnson 5.19% 4.77% 5.40%
1976 IV 6,451 1,710 4,741 Nixon/Ford 2.73% -0.09% 3.94%
1980 IV 7,316 1,842 5,474 Carter 3.19% 1.87% 3.66%
1988 IV 9,673 2,434 7,240 Reagan 3.55% 3.55% 3.56%
1992 IV 10,559 2,593